Shop
Our Story
Chef’s Table
Locations
Account
Careers
Contact

$0.00
Where are we delivering? Please enter your zip code.

Derrick, lead butcher at 200 Schermerhorn, has been working at Brooklyn Fare since its opening in 2009. He's worked as a butcher for 22 years and has been formative in shaping the meat department into what it is today.

We prefer to source our meats from local farms and providers, and pride our meat department on its relationships with New York meat vendors. For more information about our selection, drop us a line!
Our in-store delicatessen selects some of the finest cuts of meats & cheeses, both domestic and international. Our employees are skilled and friendly, happy to help suit any of your deli needs. At our deli, we also provide a wide breadth of gourmet prepared foods, cooked at our 37th street location. For more information about our deli selection, drop us a line!
Simo, deli manager at 200 Schermerhorn, has been working at Brooklyn Fare for 6 years.

Favorite cured meat?: "Our Aged Rosetta de Lyon salami is really popular."

Favorite prepared food?: "I really love our homemade veggie burgers, prepared fresh daily at our 37th street kitchen. I usually put them on 7-grain rolls with some fresh pepper jack cheese, avocado, arugula, oil and balsamic, pressed into a panini. Delicious."
Karim, lead fromager at 200 Schermerhorn, has been working at Brooklyn Fare since 2012. Before Brooklyn Fare, Karim worked as a cheese merchant in Toulouse, France for 19 years. Originally born in Algeria, Karim's diverse experience and passion for cheese have fostered a superb home at Brooklyn Fare: a boutique, specialized selection in the corner of your local market.
Favorite cheese lately?: "Abbaye de Belloc is a fantastic semi-hard, sheep's milk cheese. We import it from the Pays Basque region in France. It's creamy, smooth, with a nice finish; perfect before or after a meal."

Funky wild card cheese?: "Saint Albray from France is a more adventurous option. It's soft and creamy with a washed rind, strong bite, and a bitter, earthy finish."
At Brooklyn Fare, we source the majority of our seafood from local East-coast fish and shellfish vendors. Whether its fresh seabass from Montauk, or Mahogany clams from Maine, or wares are guaranteed fresh. We’re happy to be part of a long history of seafood trade in New York City and actively supply some of NYCs best restaurants with fresh fish. Email our seafood department at fish@brooklynfare.com for more info.
John, lead fish monger at 200 Schermerhorn. Has been working at Brooklyn Fare for 6 years. Favorite fish? “Our wild-caught striped bass from Montauk is very fresh. I like to cook it simply in butter, with garlic, a little bit of thyme, and lemon juice.

Grocery


Best. Bodega. Ever. 

FAVORIT STRAWBERRY PRESERVES
10105753668

FAVORIT STRAWBERRY PRESERVES

$5.59 / 12.3 OZ

Add to Cart
NUTELLA FERRERO HAZELNUT SPREAD WITH SKIM MILK & COCOA
10104249988

NUTELLA FERRERO HAZELNUT SPREAD WITH SKIM ...

$8.99 / 26.5 OZ

Add to Cart
SMUCKER'S CONCORD GRAPE JAM
10105537732

SMUCKER'S CONCORD GRAPE JAM

$3.19 / 12/OZ

Add to Cart
BRAD'S ORGANIC CRUNCHY PEANUT BUTTER
10105098756

BRAD'S ORGANIC CRUNCHY PEANUT BUTTER

$6.99 / 18 OZ

Add to Cart
JIF NATURAL CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER
10103906564

JIF NATURAL CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER

$3.79 / 16 OZ

Add to Cart
JIF EXTRA CHUNCHY PEANUT BUTTER
10105309828

JIF EXTRA CHUNCHY PEANUT BUTTER

$3.79 / 16 OZ

Add to Cart
JIF REDUCED FAT CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER
10102169284

JIF REDUCED FAT CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER

$3.79 / 16 OZ

Add to Cart
NUTELLA FERRERO HAZELNUT SPREAD WITH SKIM MILK & COCOA
10104260292

NUTELLA FERRERO HAZELNUT SPREAD WITH SKIM ...

$4.99 / 13 OZ

Add to Cart
SMUCKER'S NO SALT ADDED CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER
10105536836

SMUCKER'S NO SALT ADDED CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER

$3.29 / 12 OZ

Add to Cart
SMUCKER'S RED RASPBERRY PRESERVES
10105537284

SMUCKER'S RED RASPBERRY PRESERVES

$3.99 / 12 OZ

Add to Cart
PETER PAN CHUNKY PEANUT BUTTER
10104508612

PETER PAN CHUNKY PEANUT BUTTER

$4.09 / 16.3 OZ

Add to Cart
SMUCKER'S APRICOT PRESEVES
10105868100

SMUCKER'S APRICOT PRESEVES

$2.99 $4.39 / 18 OZ

Add to Cart
PETER PAN CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER
10104508356

PETER PAN CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER

$4.09 / 16.3 OZ

Add to Cart
ONCE AGAIN ORGANIC CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER
10103158020

ONCE AGAIN ORGANIC CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER

$9.99 / 16 OZ

Add to Cart
WOWBUTTER CRUNCHY  TASTE JUST LIKE PEANUT BUTTER - 100% PEANUT BUTTER FREE
10103668420

WOWBUTTER CRUNCHY TASTE JUST LIKE PEANUT ...

$7.49 / 17.6 OZ

Sold out.
WOODSTOCK PEANUT BUTTER SMOOTH NO SALT
10105898436

WOODSTOCK PEANUT BUTTER SMOOTH NO SALT

from $10.99 / 16 OZ

Add to Cart
SMUKER'S REDUCED FATCREAMY PEANUT BUTTER
10105536004

SMUKER'S REDUCED FATCREAMY PEANUT BUTTER

$3.79 / 16/OZ

Add to Cart
SMUKER'S NATURAL CRUNCHY PEANUT BUTTER
10103659012

SMUKER'S NATURAL CRUNCHY PEANUT BUTTER

$4.29 / 16 OZ

Sold out.
SMUCKERS STRAWBERRY SYRUP
10105867908

SMUCKERS STRAWBERRY SYRUP

$3.89 / 12 OZ

Add to Cart
SMUCKERS STRAWBERRY SPREAD - SQUEEZE
10104095172

SMUCKERS STRAWBERRY SPREAD - SQUEEZE

$3.99 / 20 OZ

Add to Cart
SMUCKER'S SUNDAE CARMEL
10105536324

SMUCKER'S SUNDAE CARMEL

$3.89 / 20/OZ

Add to Cart
SMUCKER'S SUGAR FREE HOT DUDGE TOPPING
10105535876

SMUCKER'S SUGAR FREE HOT DUDGE TOPPING

$3.49 / 11.75 OZ

Sold out.
SMUCKER'S REDUCED FAT CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER
10104345220

SMUCKER'S REDUCED FAT CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER

$3.79 / 16 OZ

Sold out.
SMUCKER'S PINEAPPLE TOPPING
10105538436

SMUCKER'S PINEAPPLE TOPPING

$3.79 / 12/OZ

Add to Cart
SMUCKER'S PEACH PRESERVES
10105537604

SMUCKER'S PEACH PRESERVES

$3.19 / 12 OZ

Add to Cart
SMUCKER'S MAGIC SHELL CHOCOLATE FUDGE
10105536452

SMUCKER'S MAGIC SHELL CHOCOLATE FUDGE

$2.99 / 7.25 OZ

Add to Cart
SMUCKER'S HOT FUDGE TOPPING
10105538116

SMUCKER'S HOT FUDGE TOPPING

$2.99 / 11.75 OZ

Add to Cart
SMUCKER'S GRAPE JELLY - SQUEEZE
10105535620

SMUCKER'S GRAPE JELLY - SQUEEZE

$3.99 / 20 OZ

Add to Cart
SMUCKER'S GOOBER PEANUT BUTTER & STRAWBERRY JELLY STRIPES
10105868292

SMUCKER'S GOOBER PEANUT BUTTER & STRAWBERR...

$3.99 / 18 OZ

Add to Cart
SMUCKER'S DARK CHOCOLATE SPECIAL RECIPE
10105535428

SMUCKER'S DARK CHOCOLATE SPECIAL RECIPE

$3.69 / 17.75 OZ

Add to Cart
SMUCKER'S BLUEBERRY PRESERVES
10105537988

SMUCKER'S BLUEBERRY PRESERVES

$2.99 / 12 OZ

Add to Cart
SKIPPY CHUNKY PEANUT BUTTER
10103630596

SKIPPY CHUNKY PEANUT BUTTER

$2.99 / 16.3 OZ

Add to Cart
REESE'S CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER
10105550084

REESE'S CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER

$4.99 / 18 OZ

Sold out.
REESE MINT JELLY
10105530948

REESE MINT JELLY

$3.49 / 10.5 OZ

Sold out.
PLANTERS PEANUT BUTTER CREAMY
10105552708

PLANTERS PEANUT BUTTER CREAMY

$3.69 / 16.3/OZ

Sold out.
PLANTERS CRUNCHY PEANUT BUTTER
10104669444

PLANTERS CRUNCHY PEANUT BUTTER

$3.69 / 16.3/OZ

Sold out.
MARCO POLO HAZELNUT SPREAD
10105363204

MARCO POLO HAZELNUT SPREAD

$6.49 / 12.3 OZ

Sold out.
JIF SIMPLY CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER
10105309636

JIF SIMPLY CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER

$4.39 / 17.3 OZ

Add to Cart
JIF CHOCOLATE HAZELNUT SPREAD
10104576836

JIF CHOCOLATE HAZELNUT SPREAD

$4.49 / 14.1 OZ

Sold out.
HERSHEY'S HOT FUDGE TOPPING
10105325444

HERSHEY'S HOT FUDGE TOPPING

$3.29 / 12.8 OZ

Add to Cart